The Monitor is a weekly column dedicated to all the pieces taking place within the WIRED world of tradition, from motion pictures to memes, TV to Twitter.

Across the WIRED workplaces I’m not essentially a “informed ya so” type of individual. Frankly, in a office this sensible, I’m extra of a “no, no, you’re proper” crew participant. However on Monday morning, when my colleagues hopped on Slack to speak about final Sunday’s episode of The Final of Us, all I may assume was, “I warned you.” 

Granted, I’d solely warned a pair. However as one of many editors behind Will Bedingfield’s good piece on bringing Naughty Canine’s online game to HBO and Hemal Jhaveri’s pretty Q&A with Final of Us star Pedro Pascal, I’d gotten an early peek on the present, and when anybody would ask, I’d say, “Episode 3 made me cry.”

The sequence’ third episode—a love story between a prepper, Invoice (Nick Offerman), and a person named Frank who will get trapped on his property (Murray Bartlett)—is a departure from each the HBO sequence’ major plot and the sport it’s based mostly on. Invoice is a personality within the sport, however not a playable one, and Frank is simply talked about in passing. Increasing their story was one of many some ways the present’s creators Craig Mazin and Neil Druckmann (additionally the sport’s maker) sought to rework Final of Us the sport into Final of Us the status TV present. “I mentioned, ‘Neil, I’ve acquired a loopy thought,’” Mazin informed Vainness Honest. “And he was like, ‘Do it. Let’s see the way it goes.’”

The gambit labored. Sunday’s airing of “Lengthy Lengthy Time” garnered 6.4 million viewers, a 12 p.c improve from the earlier episode and 1.8 million greater than the sequence premiere. (This bump is critical contemplating Final of Us’ community sibling, Home of the Dragon, was already dropping viewers by its third episode.) Streams for the Linda Ronstadt track from which the episode acquired its title went up 4,900 p.c on Spotify. Jimmy Kimmel had Offerman on his late-night program to present him TikToks of followers’ tearful reactions to the episode. And Twitter couldn’t cease speaking about it. Private fave: “The Final of Us writers had been like, ‘Hey, Joel wants a automobile. What if we write probably the most touching and heartbreaking hour of tv on this planet.’”

It was that uncommon episode of tv that launched a thousand assume items. Vulture declared the episode a Rosetta stone that “unlocked the variation.” Rolling Stone known as it an “achingly stunning love story.” Inverse requested director Peter Hoar to decode the ultimate shot. Multiple outlet known as it a masterpiece.

As with all discourses, there was additionally a backlash. Druckmann himself had foretold it, telling The New Yorker previous to the sequence launch that “as superior as that episode is, there are going to be followers who’re upset by it.” Druckmann’s creation has often acquired criticisms round its queer characters, and he, rightly, knew some followers wouldn’t like what his present did with Invoice’s story. Some known as it “an egregious pivot beneath the guise of constructive illustration.” Others known as it “empty sentiment.” There was speak that the episode was an instance of the “bury your gays” trope; additional critics claimed it was a subversion of that trope. (The latter is nearer to the reality.) And on and on it went.