Shortly after Hannah Dreier joined The Instances as an investigative reporter final 12 months, she talked about one thing that shocked her editor, Kirsten Danis. Whereas Hannah had been reporting a 2019 collection about immigrant youngsters on Lengthy Island falsely accused of being gang members— tales that gained a Pulitzer Prize — she seen that a number of the younger youngsters labored in a single day shifts at a cookie manufacturing facility.

Kirsten’s stunned response made Hannah marvel if there was one other story to do. “It’s type of an open secret amongst folks within the immigration world that many of those children find yourself in jobs that violate youngster labor legal guidelines,” Hannah informed me. “I spotted I had been so targeted on border and detention insurance policies that I had uncared for to report on kids’s experiences as soon as they’re truly dwelling within the U.S.”

Hannah has spent the previous 10 months reporting the story, and she or he spoke with extra 100 youngster employees in 20 states for it. This weekend, The Instances revealed her exposé.

“Migrant kids, who’ve been coming into the US with out their dad and mom in report numbers, are ending up in a number of the most punishing jobs within the nation,” Hannah writes. Many kids have labored on merchandise for big-name firms, together with Entire Meals, Walmart, J. Crew and Frito-Lay. “It’s not that we wish to be working these jobs,” mentioned Kevin Tomas, 15, who was just lately stacking cereal containers at a manufacturing facility. “It’s that we now have to assist our households.”

What to do?

Some components of the answer appear simple: If federal, state and native authorities put a better precedence on implementing current legal guidelines, they may cut back youngster labor. One a part of the reply could contain higher oversight of the so-called sponsor households — akin to foster households — with whom the youngsters are sometimes dwelling. Firms might additionally play a task by cracking down on contractors and extra rigorously checking employee identification. As Hannah mentioned, the unlawful use of kid labor is an open secret.

However fixing the underlying drawback — the latest surge of migration by each kids and adults and the chaos created by it — is extra vexing.

Over the previous few years, the variety of youngster migrants coming into the U.S. has soared for a mix of causes. Elements of Latin America, together with Honduras and Venezuela, have fallen into disarray, inflicting extra folks to depart these international locations. The Covid pandemic exacerbated the desperation.

The U.S. has responded with insurance policies which are supposed to assist, and generally do, but in addition can create an extra incentive for migration. Beginning in 2008, for instance, the U.S. made it simpler for Central American kids who arrived on the U.S.-Mexico border to stay right here and reside with sponsor households. The coverage stored kids from in any other case being stranded in Mexico — but in addition gave determined dad and mom further motive to ship their kids north in the hunt for a greater life.

Donald Trump, after all, tried to crack down on migration, together with by harsh insurance policies that separated kids from their dad and mom. President Biden ended a few of these insurance policies however has struggled to seek out a really perfect resolution.

Migration surged virtually as quickly as he took workplace, partly as a result of migrants believed Biden’s election meant that the U.S. would admit folks even when they didn’t have authorized permission to return. Final 12 months, the variety of unaccompanied minors coming into the U.S. rose to 130,000, 3 times what it was 5 years earlier, Hannah explains. The variety of adults coming into the nation additionally spiked in 2021 and 2022.

The Biden administration initially did little to discourage this enhance. After harsh criticism from Republicans and complaints from some Democratic officers who mentioned their cities and states couldn’t deal with the inflow, the administration has just lately made it more durable for undocumented immigrants to enter the U.S. The brand new insurance policies have begun having their supposed impact, however now many liberals are criticizing the administration as heartless: Extra immigrants could also be stranded in Mexico, and fewer will be capable to go away the troubles of their house international locations.

The persevering with debate has highlighted the vexing nature of immigration coverage. The federal authorities wants to decide on between turning folks away and successfully encouraging a surge of unplanned immigration.

Whether or not the nation ought to return to Nineteenth-century patterns of grueling work shifts for youngsters appears easier. You may learn Hannah’s story — and see images by Kirsten Luce — right here.

NEWS

Extreme Climate

Worldwide

Different Large Tales

• Non-public messages launched in a lawsuit revealed Fox Information hosts had been skeptical of election fraud claims in 2020. See the texts.

• A medical aircraft crashed in Nevada, killing 5 folks.

FROM OPINION

“I’m tremendous frightened about him”: Nicholas Kristof interviewed the daughter of Aleksei Navalny, Russia’s imprisoned opposition chief.

Jimmy Carter is a builder. Marjorie Taylor Greene, the brand new face of Georgia politics, is a destroyer, Maureen Dowd writes.

The issue with A.I. isn’t a lot the know-how; it’s how firms will use it, Ezra Klein writes.

Lives lived: Robert Hébras was the final survivor of a 1944 Nazi bloodbath in France. He died this month at 97.

BOOKS