Star Trek: Picard is a present that, for its first two seasons, vacillated wildly between whether or not or not it wished to be a self-serious have a look at how time had modified and wounded Jean-Luc Picard, or a daring, usually unhinged heroic journey for its titular hero. Its third season has been as sturdy as it’s nostalgic, however its midway level feels prefer it’s lastly synthesized these two halves into some unimaginable tv.

“Imposters” marks the midway level for Picard’s third and remaining season, and after final week ended the primary section of the season and the quick menace of Vadic—for now not less than—the time has come for every one in every of our heroes to reckon with the return of the Changelings. That’s, till Captain Shaw thinks he’s about to get the one-up on Riker and Picard by gloating that he has alerted Starfleet to expedite bringing the outdated buddies in to face the music for his or her insubordination. The USS Intrepid arrives to carry Picard and Riker in, however first a knife must be twisted when it’s revealed that the officer liable for investigating them for treason is none apart from one in every of Jean-Luc’s greatest regrets:

Michelle Forbes is again as Ro Laren, the Bajoran former Subsequent Technology Starfleet ensign and protégé of Captain Picard aboard the Enterprise, turned Maquis defector in what was Subsequent Technology’s remaining storyarc earlier than “All Good Issues…” introduced the present to a detailed. In a sea of nostalgic TNG returns this season, Ro’s return being saved as a pleasing shock is refreshing. But what’s much more refreshing is that Picard manages to superbly examine and conclude her arc with Picard, begined all these many years in the past, in a manner that’s not merely nostalgic, however reflective of a brand new dramatic ethos underpinning this returned Changeling menace. In a world the place these rogue denizens of the Nice Hyperlink are actually higher than ever at infiltrating the solids’ ranks, it’s not know-how and scans that may root them out. It’s good quaint relationships and connections—and in Picard and Ro Laren’s case, quite a lot of grief and trauma to wade by way of.

From the get-go, Ro’s surprising return into Picard’s orbit is primed for 2 issues. The first is fiery battle: though Riker is free-wheelingly understanding with the now Commander Ro, Picard is livid, and not simply because Ro of all folks is the one investigating him for treason. Here is Jean-Luc Picard, the irascible Admiral who falls out and in of favor with Starfleet like it’s going out of trend, at this second of emotional vulnerability—he has simply turn into a father, in any case—being preached to, lectured at by one of many few folks to harm him essentially the most in his total life? This season has been about presenting a Picard we’ve hardly ever seen at occasions, and that features quite a lot of ugly feelings the reserved man normally retains tight to his chest. But there’s none of that tightness right here; all of it falls out as Ro and Picard choose up nearly precisely the place they left off when she defected to the Maquis in TNG’s “Preemptive Strike,” and amplify all that remorse and anger throughout almost three many years of time.

The opposite priming after all is that we’re going to anticipate that the key of the season’s huge dangerous is now out, that Ro is a Changeling. In his blind fury and disgrace, Picard throws himself into it to attempt to make his manner out of confronting why Ro is right here and now and again in Starfleet. In spite of everything, Ro left Starfleet for some extraordinarily legitimate causes, and even with a lot time handed, her look right here at this second of all moments is instantly suspicious—her clipped, skilled tone; the way in which she units up the Titan to have as few crew left aboard as potential whereas her safety officers sweep for Jack Crusher (who, by the by, is having a hell of a time with these creepy visions, resulting in a horrifying second the place he goes numb and coldly executes 4 Changelings who discover him hiding in plain sight in a Starfleet uniform among the many Titan crew); even, as Picard goes on to notice to Ro, the actual fact she now not wears the standard Bajoran earring she fiercely fought to put on as an Ensign, despite Starfleet’s uniform guidelines. The setup is there, and Picard is aware of it as a lot as its hero does, and the episode spends loads of time main you down this anticipated path.

However fortunately Picard is best on this second—an evolution of maturity that I’m not fairly certain prior seasons would’ve been able to—than that, and Ro brings Picard into the Titan’s holodeck recreation of 10 Ahead for an unimaginable, explosively emotional coup de grace. It’s virtually a screaming match in a manner we’ve hardly ever ever seen Star Trek do, as all this damage and disappointment pours out from the 2 of them. “You broke my coronary heart,” Picard wails, and it feels so earnestly actual, as Ro matches him in ache: “And you broke mine!” It’s right here that the masks lastly lifts. For all of the Changelings have advanced to keep away from conventional types of detection customary by Starfleet in the Dominion Battle, making them higher infiltrators than ever earlier than, they can not duplicate the unifying energy of grief, the damage it conjures up in folks and the damage that grief then is then in flip inflicted on different folks. Each equally skewered by the opposite, Picard and Ro realise that they’re each who they are saying they’re, and the latter can ultimately reveal her true intentions—the Changelings have already compromised Starfleet with plans to assault it throughout Frontier Day, and Ro is among the remaining loyalists who has been investigating what’s happening.

That is the sort of nostalgia that Picard rightfully wields with a fragile and efficient contact, and much simpler than simply having outdated faces present up for the journey as a result of that’s enjoyable and good. Is the top end result nonetheless largely the identical—a well-known good friend (or actually frenemy, with Ro) coming in to set the heroes on a path to victory? Sure, however it’s faraway from the rose-tinted view of Picard as this mythic legend, and totally exposes simply how devastating one in every of his biggest failures as a captain has haunted him within the time that has handed between these two reveals. That is the sort of examination that Picard’s first season was too scared to decide to, and that its second was too busy being completely bonkers to even think about—and within the second, it really works completely, tying a bow on a personality arc that had lingered for generations after TNG, whereas establishing the stakes of this new “remaining” chapter in Picard’s story.

However after all, not all issues may be really completely satisfied after this second of catharsis. Having confided her investigation within the remaining Titan crew and prepared to return to her ship and proceed the work there, Ro finds that she herself has been compromised: the Intrepid is in Changeling palms, and after she kills the 2 shapeshifting officers on her shuttle she finds a bomb planted to silence her. In a single final act of touching religion, Ro sends a message to the Titan warning them, and Picard discovers that Ro’s earring, gifted to him as a farewell and reconciliation, is holding all the information of her Changeling analysis thus far—as he’s compelled to observe her make a hit-and-run sacrifice on the Intrepid, smashing her shuttle into its warp nacelles so the uncompromised Titan can escape.

It’s a tragic however superbly bittersweet finish to one in every of The Subsequent Technology’s unsung and most advanced of characters, and a suitably highly effective re-enforcement of the stakes at play as Picard season three enters its endgame. With all our heroes thus far reunited, as Raffi and Worf beam aboard the Titan with info in tow concerning the secrets and techniques of the Daystrom Station, the die is forged for Starfleet’s best to save lots of the day as soon as once more—at the same time as a kind of best heroes provides their lives for that combating probability.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to anticipate the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and every thing it’s worthwhile to learn about the way forward for Physician Who.