What do Cardi B, Tesla, former Trump White Home Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci, and MSNBC host Ali Velshi all have in widespread?

They’re all former subscribers to Twitter Blue, Twitter’s paid subscription plan, just lately revamped by proprietor and CEO Elon Musk, which gives blue checkmarks to anybody who pays $8 per 30 days (or $11 per 30 days if subscribing by way of an iOS gadget). Sure, even Tesla, an organization the place Musk can also be CEO, seems to have unsubscribed.

New Twitter Blue subscriber knowledge launched(Opens in a brand new tab) by on-line researcher Travis Brown highlights that simply two months after Twitter relaunched the paid Twitter Blue tier on its platform, it seems subscription numbers could already be beginning to stagnate. 

Moreover, a new report(Opens in a brand new tab) from journalist Steven Monacelli in Gizmodo highlights that numerous Twitter Blue verified customers who’ve stopped subscribing to the platform but their blue checkmark nonetheless stays energetic on their account. A few of these customers who spoke to Monacelli canceled their subscriptions months in the past, but their account continues to be marked as subscribing to Twitter Blue although they haven’t paid.

As Brown confirmed to me, these non-paying Twitter Blue customers could be tracked as subscribers by way of the Twitter API, which is what the researcher makes use of to observe subscription knowledge. Brown seen that a few of the customers reported on within the Gizmodo piece have been amongst those that have been lastly unsubscribed within the newest knowledge. Monacelli has additionally confirmed that there are customers he spoke to that also have the Twitter Blue badge even after his report and Brown’s newest knowledge launch. 

Over the previous week, 26,319 Twitter customers both unsubscribed or have been faraway from paid Twitter Blue plans in line with Brown’s Feb. 12 knowledge launch. A few of these unsubscribed customers embrace notable Twitter customers, like rapper Cardi B, talked about above. This could additionally mark the primary time Twitter Blue skilled a lower in subscribers so far as public monitoring of this knowledge goes.

There are some caveats to this tracked knowledge, Brown tells me. Twitter typically removes energetic Twitter Blue customers with a purpose to confirm them if they modify their show identify. These customers would often seem as Twitter Blue subscribers as soon as once more. As well as, the one method for third-parties to trace Twitter Blue subscriptions is thru Twitter’s public API, and there is a risk that it typically misses new subscribers.

As well as, we now know by way of the Gizmodo report that some Twitter Blue customers truly unsubscribe wherever from weeks to months earlier than truly being eliminated, so their cancellations might not be counted till a while later. With that being mentioned, the latest inner Twitter Blue subscriber knowledge printed in a report(Opens in a brand new tab) in The Info, discovered that Brown’s estimates have been extraordinarily shut(Opens in a brand new tab).

So, what number of paying Twitter Blue subscribers does Twitter even have? That beforehand talked about report(Opens in a brand new tab) from The Info found that Twitter had 180,000 Twitter Blue subscribers within the U.S. as of mid-January, with an estimated whole of 290,000 subscribers worldwide.

In 2021, the 12 months earlier than Musk acquired the corporate, Twitter generated over $5 billion in income. Advert income made up(Opens in a brand new tab) greater than 90% of that quantity. Since Musk’s takeover, half of Twitter’s prime advertisers stopped operating adverts on the platform. Musk launched his model of Twitter Blue envisioning a subscription-based mannequin that might assist make up for these losses.

Primarily based on the newest inner knowledge, Twitter is pulling in simply lower than $28 million a 12 months…if all of these 290,000 Twitter Blue subscribers have been truly paying, which we now know they don’t seem to be.